Psychology Article Critique Help: How to Write a Critical Review of a Psychology Paper

Psychology Article Critique Help: How to Write a Critical Review of a Psychology Paper
Psychology Article Critique Help

Image from istockphoto

Writing a critique of a psychology paper is a common assignment for students who are studying psychology or related fields. A critique is a critical evaluation of a work that assesses its strengths and weaknesses, as well as its relevance, accuracy, and structure. A critique is not just a summary or a personal opinion, but a reasoned analysis that supports a clear thesis statement.

If you are looking for psychology article critique help, you are in the right place. In this article, we will guide you through the steps of writing a psychology critique paper, from choosing a topic and conducting research to writing and formatting your paper. We will also provide you with some tips and examples to help you improve your skills and confidence as a psychology writer.

Step 1: Choose a Topic and a Psychology Article to Critique

The first step of writing a psychology critique paper is to choose a topic and a psychology article to critique. You may be assigned a specific topic or article by your instructor, or you may have some freedom to choose one that interests you. Either way, you should make sure that the topic and the article are relevant to your course and the field of psychology.

Some possible sources of psychology articles to critique are:

  • Academic journals, such as the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, the Journal of Abnormal Psychology, or the Journal of Experimental Psychology. These are peer-reviewed publications that contain original research and reviews of the literature on various topics in psychology. You can access them through your library or online databases, such as PsycINFO or Google Scholar.
  • Popular magazines, such as Psychology Today, Scientific American Mind, or The Psychologist. These are non-peer-reviewed publications that aim to inform and entertain the general public about psychology and related topics. They often feature articles that summarize or comment on recent research findings, trends, or controversies in psychology. You can find them in print or online, but be aware that they may not be as rigorous or reliable as academic journals.
  • Websites, blogs, podcasts, or videos, such as the American Psychological Association, the British Psychological Society, or TED Talks. These are online platforms that provide information, education, or entertainment on psychology and related topics. They may feature articles, interviews, lectures, or demonstrations by experts, practitioners, or enthusiasts in psychology. You can access them through the internet, but be careful to evaluate their credibility and quality before using them as sources.

Once you have chosen a topic and a psychology article to critique, you should read it carefully and critically. Take notes of the main points, arguments, evidence, and conclusions of the article. Identify the strengths and weaknesses of the article, as well as any questions or comments you have. You can use the following questions to guide your reading and note-taking:

  • What is the main purpose or goal of the article? What is the research question or hypothesis that the article addresses?
  • What is the theoretical framework or perspective that the article adopts? How does it relate to the existing literature or knowledge on the topic?
  • What is the methodology or design of the article? How did the authors collect and analyze the data? What are the main variables, measures, and procedures involved?
  • What are the main results or findings of the article? How do they support or reject the research question or hypothesis? How do they compare or contrast with other studies on the topic?
  • What are the main implications or applications of the article? How do they contribute to the advancement of the field or the solution of a problem? What are the limitations or challenges of the article? How do they affect the validity or generalizability of the results?
  • What is your overall evaluation or opinion of the article? Do you agree or disagree with the authors’ claims, arguments, or conclusions? Why or why not? What are the strengths and weaknesses of the article? How could it be improved or extended?

Step 2: Conduct Additional Research on the Topic and the Article

The second step of writing a psychology critique paper is to conduct additional research on the topic and the article. This will help you to deepen your understanding of the topic, to compare and contrast the article with other sources, and to support your critique with evidence and examples.

You can use the same sources that you used to find the article to critique, such as academic journals, popular magazines, or online platforms. You can also use other sources, such as books, reports, or dissertations, that may provide more comprehensive or in-depth information on the topic. You can search for these sources using keywords, titles, authors, or references related to the topic and the article.

When conducting additional research, you should focus on finding sources that are relevant, reliable, and recent. Relevance means that the sources address the same or a similar topic or question as the article. Reliability means that the sources are credible, authoritative, and accurate. Recent means that the sources are up to date and reflect the current state of knowledge or debate on the topic.

As you conduct additional research, you should take notes of the main points, arguments, evidence, and conclusions of the sources. You should also evaluate the sources using the same criteria that you used to evaluate the article, such as purpose, perspective, methodology, results, implications, and limitations. You should compare and contrast the sources with the article, as well as with each other, to identify similarities, differences, agreements, disagreements, gaps, or inconsistencies. You should also note any questions or comments you have about the sources.

Step 3: Develop a Thesis Statement for Your Psychology Critique Paper

The third step of writing a psychology critique paper is to develop a thesis statement for your paper. A thesis statement is a concise and clear statement that summarizes the main point or argument of your paper. It tells the reader what your paper is about, what your position or perspective is, and what you intend to prove or demonstrate in your paper.

A good thesis statement for a psychology critique paper should:

  • Be specific and focused on the topic and the article
  • Be debatable and arguable, not obvious or factual
  • Be clear and coherent, not vague or confusing
  • Be original and creative, not boring or cliché

For example, a bad thesis statement for a psychology critique paper on an article about the effects of social media on mental health would be:

  • Social media has both positive and negative effects on mental health. (This is too broad and general, not specific and focused)
  • Social media is bad for mental health. (This is too simple and factual, not debatable and arguable)
  • Social media affects mental health in many ways. (This is too vague and confusing, not clear and coherent)
  • Social media is the devil. (This is too extreme and cliché, not original and creative)

A good thesis statement for a psychology critique paper on the same article would be:

  • The article by Smith and Jones (2023) fails to provide convincing evidence that social media use causes depression and anxiety among adolescents, as it relies on a flawed methodology, a biased sample, and a weak theoretical framework. (This is specific and focused, debatable and arguable, clear and coherent, and original and creative)

Step 4: Write an Outline for Your Psychology Critique Paper

The fourth step of writing a psychology critique paper is to write an outline for your paper. An outline is a plan or a blueprint that organizes the main ideas and supporting details of your paper. It helps you to structure your paper logically, coherently, and consistently. It also helps you to avoid repetition, omission, or digression in your paper.

An outline for a psychology critique paper typically consists of three main parts: an introduction, a body, and a conclusion. Each part has its own purpose and components, as follows:

  • Introduction: The introduction is the first paragraph of your paper that introduces the topic, the article, and the thesis statement of your paper. It should:
    • Provide some background information or context on the topic and the article
    • Identify the title, author, and publication of the article
    • Summarize the main purpose, argument, and conclusion of the article
    • State your thesis statement clearly and concisely
  • Body: The body is the main part of your paper that develops and supports your thesis statement with evidence and analysis. It should:
    • Be divided into several paragraphs, each with a clear topic sentence that relates to your thesis statement
    • Provide specific examples, quotations, or paraphrases from the article and other sources to illustrate your points
    • Explain how the evidence supports or refutes your points, and how it relates to the article and the topic
    • Address any counterarguments or alternative perspectives that may challenge your points, and explain why they are weak or invalid
    • Use transitions and connectors to link your paragraphs and points logically and smoothly
  • Conclusion: The conclusion is the last paragraph of your paper that summarizes the main points and restates the thesis statement of your paper. It should:
    • Remind the reader of the topic, the article, and the thesis statement of your paper
    • Synthesize the main points and evidence from the body of your paper
    • Emphasize the significance or implications of your critique for the field or the problem
    • Provide some suggestions or recommendations for further research or action on the topic

Here is an example of an outline for a psychology critique paper on the same article and thesis statement as above:

  • Introduction:
    • Background: Social media use among adolescents has increased dramatically in recent years, raising concerns about its effects on mental health
    • Article: The article by Smith and Jones (2023) claims that social media use causes depression and anxiety among adolescents, based on a survey of 1,000 high school students
    • Summary: The article argues that social media use leads to lower self-esteem