A Breach of Trust: Ethical and Legal Landmines in Medical Practice

Imagine a seemingly simple medical visit gone wrong. A medical assistant, Stephanie, prescribes medication to a patient – but there’s a catch. Stephanie lacks the authorization to do so. This scenario exposes a web of ethical and legal implications for everyone involved, from Stephanie herself to the supervising practitioner and the medical practice as a whole. Let’s delve into the potential consequences for each party.

Medical Assistant (Step..):

Stephanie’s actions raise serious concerns. Stepping outside her designated role by prescribing medication is not only unethical, but also illegal. Medical assistants have a specific scope of practice, and medication prescription falls outside of those boundaries (Spetz et al., 2019). This unauthorized act could lead to legal repercussions for Stephanie, potentially including disciplinary action or even license revocation.

Nurse Practitioner (Me):

As the designated prescribing provider, you also face ethical questions. Prescribing medication without proper authorization suggests a potential breakdown in communication or documentation within the care team. This failure to follow protocol could be interpreted as a violation of your ethical obligations as a healthcare professional (Perloff et al., 2017). Legally, unauthorized prescribing carries significant weight. Disciplinary action from the state licensing board or even malpractice lawsuits could arise if the unauthorized medication causes harm to the patient.

Medical Director:

The medical director shoulders the ultimate responsibility for ensuring everyone in the practice adheres to legal and ethical standards. Failing to address issues like unauthorized prescribing or communication gaps within the team constitutes an ethical lapse. If a lack of supervision or monitoring led to Stephanie’s actions, the medical director might face legal consequences as well. Potential repercussions include liability for the actions of staff members, which could translate to financial penalties or even legal claims from patients.


The medical practice itself is not absolved of responsibility. It’s the practice’s duty to ensure all patient care activities fall within legal and ethical frameworks. Ignoring unauthorized prescriptions or communication breakdowns, as in this scenario, can severely damage the practice’s reputation and erode patient trust. Legally, the practice could face regulatory penalties, financial fines, or even lawsuits from patients harmed by unauthorized prescriptions (Perloff et al., 2017).


  • How can such ethical and legal issues be prevented? Clear communication protocols, established scopes of practice, and robust staff training are all crucial in safeguarding patient well-being and preventing ethical and legal pitfalls.
  • What are the ethical principles that guide medical practice? Principles like patient autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice are the cornerstones of ethical healthcare delivery.
  • What recourse do patients have if they suspect unauthorized medication administration? Patients have the right to know who is involved in their care and the qualifications of those providing treatment. If they have concerns, they can voice them to the practice directly or file a complaint with the state licensing board.

By understanding the ethical and legal implications of unauthorized medical practices, healthcare professionals can work together to create a safer environment for both patients and staff. Remember, open communication, adherence to established protocols, and a commitment to ethical principles are the cornerstones of a trustworthy and legally compliant healthcare practice.

Leave a Reply